Top 10 Local Burger Joints in Central Indiana

10 Great Local Burger Joints in Central Indiana

Find the right local burger joint in Central Indiana with this list. Are you ready to sit down for a fresh beef burger and some delicious homemade fries? You’ll find what you are looking for today!

In fact, the hardest part will be picking just one to start with. You may find yourself joining “food groups” or writing about food! What’s funny is that before too long, if you try each and every one of these local burger joints, you will be an official “foodie” as you gobble down burger after burger!

Punch Burger

12525 Old Meridian Street, #100
Carmel, IN 46032

Enjoy Angus beef patties and chicken breasts straight from Midwest farmers at Punch Burger! The establishment was started by two guys from Indiana who wanted to find a quality burger and beer at a reasonable price! Boy, did they ever succeed!

One thing you can expect from Punch Burger is the highest quality meat with the best service. The joint prides itself on being nothing short of the best and accomplishes this with teamwork, exceptional communication, and service with a smile!

This burger joint was rated by Yandly as one of the top two restaurants to check out in Indianapolis! Urbanspoon even rated Punch Burger as one of the top 25 family-friendly restaurants in the United States!

Flamme Burger Keystone

8487 Union Chapel Road, Suite 560
Indianapolis, Indiana 46240

Flamme Burger Keystone is well-known for the customizable menu options they offer and the quality of products they produce and serve. Your taste buds will be amazed by every delicious bite at this burger joint.

This restaurant has a wood-fired grill, gourmet burgers, seafood, salads, chicken, and more! You are sure to find something to please everyone in the entire family, even those picky eaters who don’t like to try anything new. They even have specialty desserts that are sure to fire up your sweet tooth as soon as you walk in the door!

Flamme Burger Keystone aims for the freshest quality all-natural beef burgers seasoned with a special blend of Flamme seasonings. You may not discover the closely-guarded secret to their delicious burgers or the blend of their special Flamme seasoning, but you’ll surely get to taste their wonder on your visit!

With fresh-cut fries, tasty homemade dressings, customizable sandwiches, and signature shakes, it’s no wonder they are one of the top burger joints in Indiana. Enjoy a salted caramel or vanilla bean gelato shake or homemade milkshake in delicious flavors like strawberry shortcake, red velvet, double espresso, and chocolate peanut butter!

Between the Bun: Burgers, Dogs, and More

2222 West Southport Road, Suite A
Indianapolis, Indiana 46217

Between the Bun has unique options for the foodies out there to try and enjoy! It’s no wonder they are rated as highly as they are with the many available food choices they have for everyone who visits!

Established in 2012, Between the Bun has award-winning burgers, hot dogs, and more! They go for “creative concoctions” every time with only the freshest products! They have been voted as one of the latest and greatest burger joints in Indiana and the best hot dog shop in Indiana! They pride themselves on creating one-of-a-kind burgers!

You can enjoy smoked, pulled pork, chicken, and beef patties with delicious hot dogs for an all-American treat! With their signature seasonings and sauces, you are sure to find something yummy at Between the Bun!

Burger Theory

8555 Stansted Drive
Indianapolis, IN 46241

This burger joint (Burger Theory) is excited to offer custom burgers and craft beer! They enjoy reinventing classic dishes and providing customers with customizable options. In fact, the “Create Your Own Menu” offers you 4,320 possibilities for your lunch or dinner!

Who could ask for more variety? Plus, you’ll get to chow down on many options, never getting sick of one standard meal. Although you can, of course, eat your family favorites every time you go, you’ll probably want to try something original from time to time.

Burger Theory is sure to impress you with its innovative layout and rustic design – the perfect atmosphere for fun, friends, and lively gatherings! Many patrons meet up at Burger Theory as they offer a fun atmosphere that anyone can enjoy! It’s a favorite local hang-out for sure!

This burger joint has delicious house-made mini-desserts, onion rings, certified Angus beef burgers, wraps, fresh salads, sandwiches, seafood, a selection of over 30 craft beers and wines – to name a few choices! That sounds very delicious, especially if you are hungry and aching for something new to try!

Enjoy your mason jar dessert choice of apple crumb, carrot cake, key lime, or brownie sundae. And that list only included a few of their dessert menu items! Taste the difference offered by Burger Theory by checking them out today!

317 Burger

915 East Westfield Blvd
Indianapolis, IN 46220

This American family establishment serves 100% fresh premium Black Angus beef burgers, hand-cut fries, truffle parmesan fries, seafood, sandwiches, and salads – something for everyone on the guest list of your next party.

Have you ever tried truffle fries? They will change the way you look at fries from this point forward! You’ll never want normal fries ever again! Taste it for yourself at this burger joint and see what the difference is!

Enjoy one of their 15 tap beers while you play darts with your friends! There’s a creative option for all tastes at 317 Burger! What are you waiting for?!?

Indy’s Burger Joint

5015 East Stop 11 Road
Indianapolis, IN 46237

At Indy’s Burger Joint, you can taste a 100% beef patty on a pretzel bun with many more options to choose from! Imagine biting into a mixture of pretzels, the perfect bar snack, and bread, the ultimate choice for a bun! At Indy’s Burger Joint, you get the option of having the bread of your choice!

This family-owned, family-run local business prides itself on satisfying customers’ needs with its delicious hand-crafted burgers! Plus, you can support local businesses by eating from here! They even have vegan-friendly burgers available for those wanting that option!

Kuma’s Corner

1127 Prospect Street
Indianapolis, IN 46203

Located in the Fountain Square neighborhood, Kuma’s Corner has the best burgers and craft beer around! Not only that, but they offer macaroni and cheese, sandwiches, and salads. Consider trying the High on Fire Burger with Sriracha hot sauce, peppers, pineapple, prosciutto, and sweet chili paste for a real kick!

They also have unique options like the Metallica or the Led Zeppelin, which has bacon, BBQ pork, cheddar, and pickles on it. You are sure to find something you’ve never tried before at Kuma’s Corner!

Bub’s Burgers & Ice Cream

210 West Main Street
Carmel, IN 46032

Enjoy a flame-grilled, hand-patted, juicy burger at Bub’s Burgers & Ice Cream! They make their buns fresh every day and have delicious hand-dipped milkshakes in chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry flavors!

Located along the picturesque Monon Trail, this burger joint is the perfect place to stop for local families, tourists, or foodies who are looking to branch out!

For a low-fat option, try one of their unique, gourmet elk burgers, or go for their Black Angus all-beef hot dog with a side of beef chili or sweet potato waffle fries! You will surely find something delicious and unique at Bub’s!

Big Dan’s Burgers

5925 Massachusetts Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46218

This old-fashioned diner is open 24 hours a day for your convenience! When you step in the doors, you’ll enjoy the relaxed vibe with classic American food with breakfast options and homestyle burgers!

Some of their tasty and juicy options include a Coney dog, a chili burger, chili cheese fries, chili with cheddar, onions, and crackers, and pork tenderloins. Their fresh, never-frozen Midwest beef and sesame buns make them a unique place to stop and check out! Enjoy a lemonade or fruit punch as you have a blast with the family at Big Dan’s!


5130 East 10th Street
Indianapolis, IN 46219

Steer-In has been listed as one of Indy’s top restaurants, the best pork tenderloin several years in a row, and the best breakfast/lunch several years in a row. It makes you curious as to what is so great at Steer-In. Just wait until you walk in the door (or grab their take-out or have it delivered – Yes, they have many options available)!

Originating in 1960, this burger joint has classic original recipes that are to die for! With their signature burgers, homemade coleslaw, and famous cream pie, you’ll have a tough time walking away from this delicious restaurant! They offer dine-in, take-out, delivery, and catering, so you are sure to enjoy this joint for any occasion!

If you are ready for some caramelized onions on your hamburger with a sesame seed bun, you’ll find what you are looking for in this list of the top local burger joints in Central Indiana. Add a bit of tomato, onion, and American cheese, and you’ve got yourself a delicious burger.

Forget fast-food establishments! Read more about what each restaurant offers by following the links in this article. You’ll find exactly what you are looking for with this top 10 list.

I bet your mouth is watering now that you’ve read about these fantastic local burger joints in Central Indiana! You probably can’t wait for a juicy Angus beef burger with grilled onions, smoked bacon, and cheddar cheese, crinkle-cut fries, or a homemade milkshake! Am I right?

Are you looking forward to tasting one of these options today? The tricky thing will be to decide which one to try first!

There are so many great local Indiana burger joints! If we missed one you know of on this list, just let us know, and perhaps, it will make our next list!